The 2025 MLB regular season is over, and the playoff picture is complete.
The Toronto Blue Jays won their first AL East since 2015 with the Cleveland Guardians winning the AL Central after being down 15½ games behind the Detroit Tigers on July 8th while the Seattle Mariners win their first AL West title since Ichiro Suzuki's MLB rookie season in 2001.
The AL Wild Card berths belong to the New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox and the Detroit Tigers. Although the Yankees have not won a World Series since 2009, this is their 12th playoff appearance in 16 years. The Red Sox make their first post-season appearance since 2021 while the Tigers, despite their collapse in the AL Central, play October baseball for the second consecutive season.
This means the Blue Jays and Mariners get first round byes. The AL Wild Card matchups are the Yankees vs. Red Sox and the Guardians vs. Tigers. The winner of the Yankees-Red Sox series will face the Blue Jays while the Mariners will face the winner of the Guardians-Tigers
In the Senior Circuit, the Philadelphia Phillies win the NL East, the Milwaukee Brewers win the NL Central while the defending World Series champion Los Angeles Dodgers win the NL West. The Phillies have won back-to-back NL East titles, the Brewers their third consecutive NL Central title and four in the past five seasons. Meanwhile, the Dodgers have won their 12th NL West title over the past 13 seasons.
The NL Wild Card berths belong to the Chicago Cubs, San Diego Padres and the Cincinnati Reds. This is the first post-season appearance for both the Cubs and Reds since the COVID shortened 2020 campaign while this is the fourth time the Padres will play October baseball this decade.
This means the Brewers and Phillies get first round byes. The NL Wild Card matchups will see the Reds take on the Dodgers while the Cubs and Padres will face each other in the post-season for the first time since 1984 when the Padres won their first NL pennant after being down 2-0 in a best of five series. The winner of the Reds-Dodgers series will face the Phillies while the Brewers will host the winner of the Cubs-Padres series.
There are two things which trouble me. I think both the Houston Astros and New York Mets were screwed out of a possible post-season appearance. The Astros and Tigers had identical 87-75 records while the Mets and Reds had identical 83-79 records. However, the Tigers and Reds both have a chance to win a World Series because they won their regular season series against the Astros and Mets, respectively.
To me, this is antithetical to the spirit of competition and fair play. There ought to have been a Game 163 between the Astros-Tigers and the Mets-Reds.
I grant you that neither the Astros nor the Mets will illicit much in the way of sympathy. Although the Astros are nearly a decade removed from the cheating scandal that tarnished their 2017 World Series title, Houston had been in the post-season every year since. I'm sure there are a lot of baseball fans who are delighted the Astros finally got their comeuppance. As for the Mets, in the words of their great announcer Gary Cohen, "And the Mets agonizing, three-and-a-half-month, slow-motion collapse, is complete." On June 12th, the Mets had a 5½ game lead over the Phillies in the NL East owning a MLB best 45-24 record. They went 38-55 the rest of the way. Since July 27th, the Mets went 21-35.
Still, the Mets and Astros should have been given one last shot in the interest of competition and fair play.
There is a similar problem with the AL East as the both the Blue Jays and Yankees have identical 94-68 records. Yes, both get to play in the post-season. But the Blue Jays get a bye while the Yankees have to fight in the AL Wild Card matchup despite both teams sharing the best record in the Junior Circuit.
I have no doubt the 2025 post-season will be great and have nothing against the Tigers or Reds. These teams have not won a World Series since 1984 and 1990, respectively. There is a chance the Red Sox and Reds could meet in the World Series 50 years after they last met. Meanwhile, the Tigers and Cubs haven't faced off in a World Series in 80 years.
Nevertheless, the current playoff format is the by-product of dumbing down baseball by speeding up games and having the ghost runner in extra innings. Champions and chumps are determined by arbitrary criteria in the Commissioner's office instead of on the field.