Things Aren't So Smiley in Providence As Mayor Ousted By Anti-Semitic Challenger

(Providence Mayor Brett Smiley (L) & David Morales (R))

In Providence, Rhode Island, incumbent Mayor Brett Smiley was ousted in the Democratic primary by 27-year-old State Representative David Morales,

With 85% of the votes tabulated, Morales earned 54% of the vote while Smiley tallied 46% of the vote. Smiley was seeking his second term in office.

What is disturbing about Morales is that much of his campaign was centered on his hostility towards Israel and to the Jewish community at large. Not only has Morales pledged to use his platform as mayor to oppose "unconditional military aid" for Israel but he objected to Smiley attending a conference sponsored by the Combat Anti-Semitism Movement. It should also be noted that Smiley converted to Judaism during his term in office.

Morales is widely expected to prevail against Republican mayoral candidate David Talan in November. Providence hasn't had a Republican mayor since the late Buddy Cianci who eventually became an Independent.

I suspect Morales will campaign on a local referendum which calls upon the city to not invest in “foreign countries conducting ethnic cleansing, apartheid, illegal military occupation, or genocide.” No countries are named in the referendum question, but its organizers are clear in singling out Israel.

In retrospect, this turn of events is not entirely surprising. In May 2025, the Palestinian flag flew over Providence City Hall over Smiley's objections. 

It would seem that Morales is more interested than advocating for Palestinians than he is in advocating for Providence. But if the people see fit to elect Morales in November, then they will get the government they deserve.